Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Considering the constant 5-4 decisions, there's 0 chance that a new justice will be confirmed until the next President takes office


10 months? I find that unlikely. The conservatives might not LIKE it, but no 5-4 decision in the past is going to help them now.


341 days until a new President is inaugurated.. That's a long time to hold.


The Republican-controlled Senate can just hold up the nominations until whenever. In fact, Republican voters are going to demand it.

The American people should have a voice on this matter, and if the shoe was on the other foot, the dems would be saying the same thing.


Well, yeah, but that's why they elected Obama, twice.


True, but considering the circumstances, it's not going to happen until at least the next President is elected. The democrats would do the same thing.


I'm not sure about that. I lean to the left but my biggest complaint is how easily democrats get pushed around.. My guess is that after a month of editorials in the WSJ and the constant drumbeat on the trail, they'd offer to vote on a centrist candidate, the republican in office would nominate someone pretty far right, and then to save face, they'd vote anyways and lose the vote.


Considering the constant 5-4 decisions

That has nothing at all to do with how justices are confirmed. As others have pointed out, the last two Obama appointed justices were appointed in less time.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: